Gary White FlexIt Realty~Real Estate & Updates, Grand Rapids & West Michigan

head_left_image

Easy come easy go.....equity....is it real?

Home owners that have their homes listed or contemplating listing have some real concerns about equity....or should I say disappearing equity.

The key of whether the equity is real is depending on how much is left after the sale.  The equity before a sale is only speculation.  That means if you didn't have it in your hand it was speculation.  Now we can say a year ago you might have gotten more for the same home.  That is probably true....but that was a year ago.  Depending on which poll or researchers you read home prices have fallen 18% in Michigan...while some of the other areas of the country have been stable.  Even more of a market driven issue is evident by areas still showing increases in home values.  Some areas of Texas, California, Washington and pockets within Michigan show growth or neutral changes in sell prices.  That is not typical or the national market.desert

So should the market changes be a concern....absolutely.  How do people make sure they do not loose more equity?  Sell...and fast.  HOW?  There does not seem to many buyers.  Simple price your home right.  People with homes priced right sell faster...and for a higher price.  So why doesn't everyone do this?  The average seller wants to maintain the perceived equity value...and some of the less skilled Realtors are willing to let sellers chase the myth with a dream that is only a mirage that moves once you arrive.  The mirage of equity looks so good on paper....so push the price up a little...the mirage looks bigger and better.  Then reality hits with a for sale sign that sits out front of the home and the mirage looks far off in the distance and almost disappears with each passing day. 

Career real estate professionals keep a constant vigil monitoring the local and regional market fluctuations.  They look at the sellers they represent as though it was their own property for sale.  Not only do career professionals do this, they inform sellers, even when it is painful news.  The goal is to sell faster and retain that precious equity.  Remember equity has two sides....an up side and a down side.  This means that even if you sell on the down side...you also purchase on the down side.  That means you are likely to pick all the equity you lost on paper when the market comes back.  If you purchase a more expensive home....your gain is even going to be more because of the percentage in change vs value.

So stop chasing the mirage only to be disappointed......achieve your sale and find your dream home while the market is in your favor.  Think of the people that just purchased.  A home like theirs in the same neighborhood is probably selling for thousands less than when they purchased....it will come back.  They only lose if they sell.

I hope this gave you an insight into the reality and mirage factor of equity.  Call a career professional when you really want the current market facts.

Gary White, Associate Broker, serving Grand Rapids and West Michigan www.MovingGR.com  My website has over 30 Free down-loadable buyer and seller documents to help you.

Comments

Hey Gary,

YOu have much to share as always, keep the good work / blog, happy thanks giving ! :)

Ray Saenz

 

Posted by Aurora Colorado Real Estate Ray Saenz, Colorado Realtor (United Property Brokers, Inc) over 2 years ago
Hi Ray, same to you Ray, glad to see you back on a regular basis again.  Thanks for the comments Ray.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Gary,  thanks for sharing your knowledge.  We are still strong in College Station, Texas.  I would like to eventually pay off our home loan so we can live in it after retirement in a few years.....  We have been paying extra on the principle each month. I wish we would have done it from day one but we didn't.  It makes a lot of difference in cutting the length of the loan so we can have it paid.
Posted by Kay Perry (Kay Perry, Broker) over 2 years ago
Gary, you are so on target with this post.  All homeowners need to recognize that the equity in their home is only equity when they sell.   Up until that point it's the same as it is with stocks.  Worth one price one day, another a different day. 
Posted by Kris Wales - Macomb County MI real estate blog & homes for sale search site (Keller Williams Realty - Lakeside Market Center) over 2 years ago
In my opinion this is no different than the stock market.  The profits are only on paper until you actually sell.  If you wait and take a chance that it will cycle up again you may get that level of profit, but, if you must sell you get what the current market conditions dictate.
Posted by The Best Spot Realty/Waterfront Real Estate/Ooltewah Real E over 2 years ago

Hi Gary - so well put!  Homeowners really do need to pay special heed to today's market conditions, and decide if they really do need to sell now.  And if they do, they really need to price it to get it sold or just don't put it on the market.

< So stop chasing the mirage only to be disappointed......achieve your sale and find your dream home while the market is in your favor. >

This statement of yours is so on the money!  If sellers can sell in this market, they can take advantage of the great opportunities out there now for a new home, and they'll be ahead of the game when the market in their area changes, as it surely will.

Ann

Posted by Portsmouth NH Homes Condos - Ann Cummings New Hampshire REALTORĀ® (RE/MAX Coast to Coast - Portsmouth New Hampshire) over 2 years ago

Gary,

Great post.  As we continue to see fluctuations it is critical for homeowners considering a move to make sure their real estate professional is current with the market. 

Posted by Kim Peasley-Parker (AgentOwned Realty, Heritage Group, Inc.) over 2 years ago
Gary, stating the obvious. A person must consider market conditions when making choices. If you don't have to make a change it would be best to wait. We don't know how this market adjustment is going to turn out. The question is how long?
Posted by Jeanean Gendron ~ Redding & Shasta County Specialist (Coldwell Banker C & C) over 2 years ago

Your point about equity is well taken.  You can't lose what you don't have.  Equity is only an illusion until you cash it in.

Posted by Dan Forbes over 2 years ago
Gary, great post. Always enjoy reading your blogs. Hope the turkey day went well for you and your family.
Posted by * Rate A Home (Rate A Home) over 2 years ago
Hi Kay, hide sight is always 20/20 they say....your interest rate is probably very good so review the financial side of things and see if paying the house off makes sense versus a card or other debt that is at a higher rate without benefit of tax right-off...like your mortgage interest.  Thanks for the comments Kay...your market has help pretty good compared to the northern states. 
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Kris, congrats on that feature post....people do not realize they have to sell to gain or lose equity...they could be in a real win-win situation with correct pricing and purchasing in a great buyers market.  Thanks for the comments Kris.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Gayle, the thing I like about the phantom equity is ....if it is not in your pocket it isn't really yours...so, as you say, it is like the stock market.  Thanks for the comments Gayle.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Ann, I can see you have a firm grasp on how this works and your clients are very fortunate to have you.  Thanks for the comments Ann.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Kim, the importance of using a professional to guide sellers and buyers through this market has become more important than ever.  Great point.  Thanks for the comments Kim.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Jeanean, making the proper choices in this market is very elusive for some clients...using a professional can clear up a lot of the market myths and issues.  Thanks for the comments Jeanean.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Dan, many think that equity is already theirs, the actual sale reflects the reality of their equity.  Thanks for the comments Dan.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Duane, thanks for the heads up on the typo.  I thought I hit spell checker before I hit post....Enjoyed Turkey day and had a lot to be thankful for at the same time.  Thanks for all your comments Duane.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Gary--The true value of your home is what someone is willing to pay for it today...Appraisals and CMA's are a judgement but like stocks or collectibles, if there is no buyer at that price, is it really worth it? Good info and explanation!
Posted by Teri Eckholm, REALTORĀ® Anoka County Acreage & Lakeshore Homes (REMAX Specialists) over 2 years ago
Gary  -- this is a wonderful topic.  I am agree with you and you have stated the issue so well.  I think that most people understand this at some level.  I have my clients look at their own situation and determine what is best for them given their goals!  I remind them that one size does not fit all.  Each of my clients who has listed their home in this down market have sold it quickly -- gotten a "fair" return and they have gotten great "deals" on the home they bought thereafter -- which met their goals of purchasing a larger home for their growing families.
Posted by Joan Whitebook, ABR,e-Pro,CEBA Southern New Hampshire (Buyer's Option Realty Services) over 2 years ago
The mirage of equity is great!  I feel like the bad news drone lately on price.  I just wish folks would listen when I say you have the chance to make something while others get zero.  Take something.
Posted by Bethesda Real Estate ~ Bethesda Homes for Sale (Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.) over 2 years ago
Although our market is not too bad in North Central Texas, I try to keep my sellers up to date on what our market is like every 60 days.  I actually have one house that listed back in July for $112,000 because based on what was selling at the time, I listed mine as the lowest priced but within market ranges for the neighborhood.  Then about two months later, I performed another market analysis and found that prices in that neighborhood had dropped a bit.  So, we dropped the price.  Now we are headed into our third market analysis (from the original) and we are dropping again.  I think that we have gone through a fairly substantial market correction here.  Hopefully things will settle a bit and we won't have to drop the price any more!  The house is a nice, clean and in a lovely neighborhood and I'm quite surprised that it hasn't already sold.  We get a lot of compliments on the showings and no one has ever said a word on the pricing (being too high).  The most common negative I get is that although it is a wonderful home, it is just a little to small (1500 sq. ft.).   Hopefully the right buyer will come along soon! 
Posted by Carolyn Shipp Realtor Mineral Wells Texas Real Estate (United Country Cason Real Estate) over 2 years ago
Hi Terri, pretty much in a nut shell....homes value is what buyers are willing to pay, all the rest is conjecture.  Thanks for the comments Terri.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Joan, you stated the basic premise of the post...set the right price....sell and purchase a great by for your family in a market that is offers great opportunity for those willing to take advantage of it.  Thanks for the comments Joan.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Josette, keep showing and telling some clients take long to realize the real market opportunities.  If they are not willing to adjust to the market you may have to move-on.....that is hard to do at times.  Thanks for the comments Josette.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Carolyn, some of the markets are having more corrections than others.  Here is an idea for your slow mover....change your MLS remarks and advertising...."Twice the size of a Bungalow" come see for yourself, ranch in great condition"!  I change advertising techniques when showings slow or no offers...I am attracting the wrong buyers.  Thanks for the comments Carolyn...good luck with your listing.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Gary, you are right, it is only equity in our heads, and I've lost 70K in my head. Boo hoo.
Posted by Missy Caulk-Ann Arbor- Realtor(R)- Ann Arbor Real Estate (Keller Williams-Ann Arbor) over 2 years ago
The trouble is that its not necessarily inexperienced agents who are doing this.  You are just ASSUMING that's the case.  I know of several top producers in my area who basically BUY LISTINGS by supporting the mirage.  Then they spend the next six months browbeating the seller to lower the price.  These people get enough listings that eventually "sell" so they have little incentive to be "honest."  They seem to keep the advertising to a minimum - so its kind of a "list it and forget it" mentality (except to ask repeatedly for price reductions.)  Tough to fight and VERY Tempting to cave to the pressure because unless you are wiling to overprice - its almost impossible to get a listing right now.  We have LOW inventory right now - people are not putting their homes on the market.
Posted by Ruthmarie Hicks (Keller Williams Realty) over 2 years ago
Hi Missy, I lost paper equity of of 175K when I sold in Florida and moved back....but I bought for 150K under construction costs too!  Worked for me.  Thanks for the comments Missy.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Gary, good info for sellers to digest, it's all on paper until someone actually steps up and buys.
Posted by Michael Eisenberg, Bellingham Realtor (eXp Realty) over 2 years ago
Hi Ruthmarie, I was not assuming anything.  I do not consider unethical agents or statistically minimal situations as mainstream or usual to the market place.  The situation you outline hopefully will correct itself.  Some agents do stoop to new lows.  The industry, the clients and even you are blemished by this type of behavior.  Every area has different markets issues.  Listings is marketing.  Ruthmarie I appreciate your comments and frustrations....we all have them from time to time.  Keep the faith...it will work out.  Thanks for your comments Ruthmarie.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Michael, that is the the most deceiving part of the equity for sellers is the paper number they grasp too.  Thanks for the comments Michael.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Always enjoy your posts. Thanks for sharing.
Posted by Bob & Carolin Benjamin - E Phoenix Arizona Real Estate (Benjamin Realty LLC) over 2 years ago
Great comments, Gary!  It's all about the client's best interest.
Posted by Jim Wire over 2 years ago
Gary, there was nothing like hearing people say "my house is worth 40 thousand more than it was last year".  Many people, unfortunately, didn't get the message that it's not "worth" that much more except on paper.  When prices skyrocket they can fall just as fast.  Our market has gone up slow and steady and hasn't had a downturn this year. 
Posted by Chris Tesch College Station, Texas Real Estate (RE/MAX Bryan College Station) over 2 years ago
Gary, there was nothing like hearing people say "my house is worth 40 thousand more than it was last year".  Many people, unfortunately, didn't get the message that it's not "worth" that much more except on paper.  When prices skyrocket they can fall just as fast.  Our market has gone up slow and steady and hasn't had a downturn this year. 
Posted by Chris Tesch College Station, Texas Real Estate (RE/MAX Bryan College Station) over 2 years ago
Gary, I'm trying to get this point across to my sister and her husband.  She is selling her house in Colorado and found the agent who told her what she wanted to hear. 
Posted by Marchel Peterson Spring TX Real Estate E-Pro ABR (Results Realty) over 2 years ago

Gary,

I don't think a lot of Realtors understand that the moment they tell a seller what their house will sell for, the equity is locked into the mind of the seller. Anything that happens afterwards to lower the price is a loss to the seller, and perception is reality. Thanks for a great post that just might help sellers and Realtors alike to understand why it's important to price the home correctly from the start.

Posted by Andrew Trevino Wilkes-Barre Homes For Sale (TradeMark Realtors Group) over 2 years ago
Gary, no problem on the typo, would hope you would do the same for me. Have a great day, Duane
Posted by * Rate A Home (Rate A Home) over 2 years ago
Gary,
A great job of explaining "equity" and the reality of today's market.  I do agree with Andrew that Sellers latch on to "numbers" we throw out so we must be careful of what we tell them.  
Posted by Cynthia Tilghman, RealtorĀ® Onslow County NC Home Specialist (Kingsbridge Realty, Inc) over 2 years ago
Hi Bob & Carolyn, thanks for the comments.  I like wise follow your posts.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Jim, sometimes people for get who we work for....thanks for the comments Jim.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Chris, I have heard that areas of Texas, the Southwest, California pockets, even some Eastern area are still doing quite well.  But that can turn just as quickly....like your said.  Thanks for the comments Chris.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Marchel, send her a link to this post.  She will be able to see the comments and understand that equity can be a myth that stands in the way of a sale....only to see the value drop further.  Time on the market will hurt her listing just as bad as over pricing.  Thanks for the comments Marchel.  Hope you had a great Thanksgiving.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Andrew, you have a very valid point.  We are the experts and when we propose a list price the numbers game begins.  The "equity lock", so making sure to use good statistics and offer solid reasons for our suggested price is very important.  Thanks for the comments Andrew.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago
Hi Cynthia, I too think Andrew had a great point.  The "equity lock" is a mindset as soon as we propose a number.  I am very careful on providing a firm number....as in NEVER!  I offer a range of where I suspect the property will sell.  This seems to help sellers better deal with the pricing process.  Thanks for the comments Cynthia.
Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) over 2 years ago

Marchel,

so what you wrote to Gary, means that your sister did not do as you wanted?  hm...   if that's the case, I am sorry, cheers up !

Ray saenz

 

Posted by Aurora Colorado Real Estate Ray Saenz, Colorado Realtor (United Property Brokers, Inc) over 2 years ago

Great post!

Disappearing Equity or Phantom Equity! 

Some of the areas that increased in value should have never seen that much increase!

Posted by Aida Pinto Real Estate Broker/Notary Public (Pinto Realty) about 1 year ago

Hi Aida, I have to agree, some of the market increases were driven by greed and speculation.  Thanks for the comments Aida.

Posted by Gary White~ Grand Rapids Real Estate, FlexIt Realty, a call or click away! (Flexit Realty~Serving West Michigan) about 1 year ago

Participate



(optional)
What does the graphic say?